Malbec 2017

EL ENEMIGO

Malbec
2017

Country
Argentina
Regulated designation
Dénomination origine (DOC)
Region
Mendoza
Subregion
Lujan de Cuyo
Varietal(s)
Malbec 90 %
Cabernet Franc 10 %
Colour
Red
Sugar
Dry
Producer's website

About this winery

El Enemigo, “the enemy”. The struggle that most defines us in our lives is the one that we wage with our selves. We are all our own worst enemies. This is the credo behind the name on the label. The wines of El Enemigo are enigmatic, charismatic, and verging on iconoclastic. In that way the wines reflect their maker, Alejandro Vigil, an almost Picasso-like personality. “Ale”, as he is known, is the head winemaker at the iconic Bodega Catena Zapata, but he has many loves. He consults,...

See the EL ENEMIGO detail page for more information on this brand

Product notes

100% Malbec grapes from Gualtallary, Tupungato at a 1470m/ 4822ft elevation. Calcareous, Deep- Calcareous. Rocky soil.

Production notes

Wild yeast fermentation with a maximum temperature at 29º C / 84º F for 20 days, with 30 days of maceration. The wine is then aged 15 months in 100 year old foudre.

Tasting notes

Rich and concentrated, it offers aromas of black fruit, cherry and dark berryfruit on the nose followed in the palate by a full-bodied wine with flavors of spice, blackberry, black cherry, pepper and a slight floral character. The finish is elegant and lengthy.

Press reviews

Tim Atkin MW

- 95 points -

April 2016

Sourced entirely from vineyards in the cool (in both sense of the word) Uco Valley sub-region of Gualtallary, this is an outstanding blend of Malbec with 7% Cabernet Franc and 3% Petit Verdot. Dense, yet chalky, it’s a multi-layered wine where the perfumed, blackberry fruit does the talking.

See detailed press review
Vinous

- 94 points -

October 2020

Made with grapes from Gualtallary and aged for 15 months in old foudres, this Malbec, mixed with 10% Cabernet Franc, is proof of the beauty of the combination: the Franc lends the Malbec greater discipline and depth. Bright purple in the glass. The nose offers fresh cherries and plums with aromas of thyme. Gentle in the mouth, delivering fine, subtle tannins that lend framework, all with a genial freshness that brings the flavours to life and pleasantly stretches out the slightly taut palate. A delicious wine.

See detailed press review
Tim Atkin MW

- 94 points -

May 2017

This Gualtallary Malbec is co-fermented with 7% Cabernet Franc and 2% Petit Verdot and aged in older, larger oak. It’s a sappy, textured, grassy blend with the brightness and perfume that define the style at Bodega Aleanna and tangy acidity.

See detailed press review
Tim Atkin MW

- 94 points -

May 2018

Marrying Malbec with 7% Cabernet Franc and 3% Petit Verdot, this hails from cool (in both senses of the word) Gualtallary. Strikingly perfumed, with violet and graphite aromas, fine tannins, savoury blackberry fruit and skilfully handled oak.

See detailed press review
Vinous

- 93 points -

September 2021 (Vintage 2018)

The 2018 Malbec El Enemigo has an 8% portion of Cabernet Franc, both from Gualtallary in the Uco Valley, from vineyards planted in calcium rich soils and aged for 15 months in old foudres. The complex nose offers plum and a hint of ash primarily along with subtle, expansive twists of lavender and violet. In the mouth, the wine is structured around the freshness with a skinny flow for the variety and gently grippy tannins that make it agile and flavorful. Delicate and compact, the juicy freshness keeps the fruity flavors present.

See detailed press review
Vinous

- 93 points -

September 2022 (Vintage 2019)

The 2019 Malbec contains 8% Cabernet Franc and 2% Petit Verdot, all from the Uco Valley, and was aged for 15 months in foudres. Purple in color. The complex nose presents fresh plum with hints of sour cherry, herbs and aromas from the aging process. In the mouth, it’s a little chalky with mild freshness and refined tannins. A relaxed, delicate, rewarding wine.

See detailed press review
James Suckling

- 93 points -

May 2022 (Vintage 2019)

This has pretty aromas of blackberries, ripe blueberries, dark chocolate, walnuts and crushed stones. Hints of citrus zest. It’s medium-bodied with fine, fleshy tannins. Textured and velvety with a solid core of dark fruit. 

See detailed press review
Descorchados

- 93 points -

2021 (Vintage 2018)

For this El Enemigo, Aleanna's entry-level malbec, winemaker Alejandro Vigil gets his grapes from a vineyard planted in the first half of the 1990s on the gravel and limestone soils of Gualtallary, in the northern Uco Valley. It's a high-altitude vineyard more than 1,300 meters up, and that shows in the type of fruit it offers, with notes of tart red fruits crossed with herbs. The palate speaks of the soil, with that firm, taut texture from the limestone. It's refreshing, and the acidity is in charge, leaving a very crisp sensation.

See detailed press review
Tim Atkin MW

- 93 points -

May 2020

The El Enemigo Malbec contains 10% Cabernet Franc - Ale Vigil is a master at blending
the two varieties - and all comes from bony soils in Gualtallary in the upper part of the Uco Valley. Fermented with 50% whole bunches, this is all about fruit and flavour rather than wood, with real zip, freshness and vibrancy, chalky minerality and fine-grained tannins.

See detailed press review
 Wine and Spirits Magazine

- 93 points -

February 2016 (Vintage 2013)

In 2009, Adrianna Catena, the youngest daughter of Nicolas Catena, joined forces with winemaker Alejandro Vigil to found Bodegas Aleanna. They’ve based their project on Adrianna Vineyard, a vineyard Catena planted around 1996, in the heights of Gualtallary. This 2013 reflects the cool temperatures of the area in the radiance of the fresh fruit and its crisp texture, propelled by an acidity so virile it nearly vibrates. Give the wine another five years in the cellar, so those flavors can evolve beyond fruitiness.

See detailed press review
James Suckling

- 93 points -

June 2015 (Vintage 2011)

Beautiful balance and freshness with dark berry, sea salt and mineral character. Full body, silky tannins and a dry finish. From grapes grown in Gualtallary. Aged in 6,000 liter 100-year-old cask.

See detailed press review
Wine Advocate

- 93 points -

March 2021 (Vintage 2018)

The 2018 Malbec has some 8% Cabernet Franc in the blend, and it has only 13.5% alcohol while retaining very good acidity. The grapes were sourced from Gualtallary and were co-fermented. It's a serious, subtle and mineral Malbec, with some austerity and shy varietal aromas of violets and wild herbs. The palate is medium-bodied with terrific texture and very clean and focused flavors, and it has the chalky texture from the limestone-rich soils. 28,000 bottles produced. It was bottled in July 2019 after 12 months in ancient oak foudres.

See detailed press review
Wine Advocate

- 93 points -

November 2022 (Vintage 2019)

It's always interesting to compare different vintages of the same wine, in this case the 2019 Malbec with the following two years. It has 8% Cabernet Franc and 2% Petit Verdot in the blend and only 13.5% alcohol while retaining very good acidity. The grapes were sourced from Gualtallary and were co-fermented. This is varietal with an herbal twist, serious, subtle and mineral with austerity and elegance, reflecting a very balanced and good year. It's medium-bodied, nicely textured and has a chalky texture from the limestone soils. 35,000 bottles produced. It was bottled in July 2020 after 15 months in ancient oak foudres. Superb!

See detailed press review
Descorchados

- 93 points -

2020 (Vintage 2017)

This is Aleanna’s most basic malbec, and like all of the house’s malbecs, it comes from the Adrianna Vineyard, 1,450 meters up in Gualtallary. The soils there are chalky, and the mountain climate marks the palate of this wine as well as its fruits. It owes those firm, tense tannins to the soil and its tart red fruits to the climate, all in a malbec that offers a very good approach to Gualtallary wines. This year’s version is particularly clean and fresh, but most of all, it’s especially nervy and tense. One of the best versions of this wine.

See detailed press review
James Suckling

- 92 points -

April 2020 (Vintage 2017)

Love the blackberry, flower and orange-peel character. Medium body, creamy tannins and a flavorful finish. This is real malbec. Total whole-berry fermentation gives this freshness and brightness. Tension to the very friendly fruit at the end.

See detailed press review
James Suckling

- 92 points -

March 2019

A fresh and focused red with cherry, balsamic and floral character. Medium to full body, soft tannins and a flavorful finish.

See detailed press review
James Suckling

- 92 points -

April 2018

A juicy and fruity red with dark berries and salt. Fresh herbs. Medium body, linear and refined with very polished tannins. Fruity and straight up but with tension.

See detailed press review
James Suckling

- 92 points -

May 2021 (Vintage 2018)

Aromas of ripe blackberries and dark cherries with herbal undertones. It’s medium-to full-bodied with chewy tannins. Fleshy with an ink-like feel on the palate. Very approachable with a flavorful finish. Delivers as always. Drink or hold.

See detailed press review
Gismondi on Wine

- 92 points -

Anthony Gismondi, October 2016 (Vintage 2011)

From Gualtallary, 1470 metres above sea level on rocky calcareous soil, this 89/6/5/ malbec/cabernet franc/petit verdot is fermented in both 225 liter barrels and old cement containers. The intense, pure black fruit is set free by the use of aged foudres for aging. The textures are round and soft, the fruit is a mix of blackberry/mulberry with a fresh, mineral, floral, licorice undercurrent. Delicious drinking even when young.

See detailed press review
Wine Spectator

- 91 points -

Kim Marcus, February 2014 (Vintage 2011)

A plush style, with concentrated and pure-tasting dark berry, violet and raspberry flavors that provide a velvety mouthfeel. Licorice and tar accents show on the long, ripe finish. 

See detailed press review
James Suckling

- 90 points -

June 2017

A soft and salty red with plum and berry character. Medium body, round texture and a flavorful finish. 

See detailed press review
Wine Spectator

- 90 points -

December 2019

Elegant, with hot stone notes accenting the pure-tasting dried red fruit flavors. Details of underbrush emerge on the focused finish, showing some tarry hints.

See detailed press review
Vinous

- 90 points -

Stephen Tanzer, July 2018

(13.5% alcohol; winemaker Alejandro Vigil vinified this wine, as well as his Bonardas, with about 30% whole clusters, vs. 50% for his vineyard-designated Cabernet Francs): Bright medium ruby. Tight, reserved scents of blackberry, licorice, violet and rose petal, with a whiff of leathery rusticity; showed riper, even slightly roasted fruits with aeration. Concentrated and refined on the palate, displaying surprising calcaire-driven energy and definition to its flavors of red and black berries and spices. Harmonious acidity and chalky floral lift give this ripe-but-dry wine a light touch (I'd even describe it as almost Pinot-like). Finishes with firm, gripping, slightly dry-edged tannins.

See detailed press review